The weekend was clearly a good one for the European Union. British Prime Minister Theresa May inked a Brexit deal which the European Commission is privately celebrating as humiliating for the UK. Moreover, at the EU summit where May put her name to an agreement that is highly controversial back home, Italian Prime Minister Giuseppe Conte indicated that his government was prepared to back away from confrontation with Brussels over its planned high-spending budget.
Conte had had a meeting with EU Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker before he suggested that his administration would look again at the budget which envisaged a deficit of 2.4 percent of GDP. Brussels had ordered Rome to redo the budget because of Italy’s high debt burden, which is 132 percent of GDP. The Commission ruled that the Conte government’s planned expenditure to meet campaign promises of minimum incomes, a raised retirement age and heavy investment to boost the sluggish economy was unsustainable, since it would pile up even more state debt. The right-wing coalition of the populist League and anti-establishment Five Star party had vowed that this, their first budget, would “end poverty”. Brussels argued that precisely the opposite would be achieved since by boosting Italian state debt, the Conte coalition was condemning future generations of Italians to a crippling albatross of indebtedness.
The Italians appear to have given in to threats that Brussels would fine Italy 0.2 percent of its GDP. For the EU’s third largest economy, this could be crippling. The fact that Brussels was entirely happy to force financially insolvent Greece into further state borrowing which at 180 percent of GDP even their own economists admitted at the time was unsustainable was conveniently ignored by EU leaders.